SRL SWISS

Can a Prosecutor Later Judge the Same Case?

Abdullah Öztürk examines Ayhan Arıkanoğlu’s individual application through two judicial records. An Istanbul indictment dated 29 June 2016 lists Arıkanoğlu among the suspects and bears the electronic signature of İrfan Fidan, then a deputy chief public prosecutor. Nine years later, Fidan was one of the two members of Türkiye’s Constitutional Court who ruled on Arıkanoğlu’s application.

On 2 October 2025, the commission declared the complaints about the trial outcome and the principle of legality in criminal law manifestly ill-founded. It dismissed the claims in a supplementary submission as out of time. The commission’s decision on admissibility determined whether those complaints would receive further constitutional review.

The article asks how Article 59 of Law No. 6216 applies when a judge previously acted as a prosecutor in the “case or matter” under examination. How much weight should a court give to the fact that a constitutional application has its own docket number and serves a different purpose? Öztürk considers the recusal provisions of Article 60 alongside the European Court of Human Rights judgments in Piersack and Micallef, which examine when doubts about impartiality are objectively justified.

The signature documents Fidan’s official connection to the indictment. The short constitutional decision gives no trial-court docket number and does not say whether withdrawal or recusal was considered. Öztürk asks what explanation of the member’s participation would allow a reader to assess the court’s impartiality on the available facts.

Read the full article (PDF)

Views: 14

Stay informed on human rights

Read our weekly Human Rights Monitor in English. Subscribe to receive it by email.

Published in Turkish, English, German, French and Italian.

Privacy and data protection