About the Submission
On 22 November 2026, SRL Swiss submitted its report on judicial independence, impartiality and lawyers’ independence in the Tahşiye proceedings to the United Nations Special Rapporteur on the independence of judges and lawyers. The English report and supporting documents were sent by email because the complete evidence bundle exceeded the online system’s file-size limit.
Scope of the Review
The review distinguishes the original investigation and January 2010 operation from the subsequent prosecution of police officers and certain media professionals. It concerns the latter defendants’ access to an independent and impartial tribunal and effective legal assistance; it does not question the acquittals in the original case. Its primary sources are judicial decisions, hearing records, court-commissioned transcripts and official correspondence.
Key Findings
The report examines the April 2015 recusal and release decisions, records concerning UYAP access and the return of release warrants, and the subsequent detention of the judges involved. It distinguishes the ECtHR’s findings on impartiality and effective review from its separate assessment of the releasing court’s jurisdiction.
Other concerns include treating an impartiality challenge as evidence of acting on instructions, relying on criticism of the court when refusing a discretionary sentence reduction, prior scrutiny of documents exchanged with counsel, restrictions on lawyer consultations and difficulties accessing 321 case-file folders. SRL Swiss assesses these matters against safeguards for judicial independence, impartial review and effective defence.
Request and Submission Status
SRL Swiss requests examination of the documented concerns, communication with the Turkish authorities and recommendations for independent review and effective remedies. The submission was sent by email on 22 November 2026. Receipt has not yet been confirmed; no assessment on the merits or finding by the United Nations is reported.
Full Report in English
Image: Illustrative cover created for SRL Swiss with AI assistance.
Stay informed on human rights
Read our weekly Human Rights Monitor in English. Subscribe to receive it by email.
Published in Turkish, English, German, French and Italian.

